799 Appendix B Derivation of Free Cash Flow, Weighted Average Cost of Capital, and Adjusted Present Value Chapter 10 demonstrated numerically the equivalence of enterprise discounted cash flow (DCF), adjusted present value (APV), and the cash-flow-to-equity valuation when leverage (as measured by the market-based debt-to-equity ratio) is constant. This appendix derives the key terms in each model—namely, free cash flow (FCF) and the weighted average cost of capital (WACC)—and demonstrates their equivalence algebraically. To simplify the analysis, we assume cash flows to equity are growing at a constant rate, g. This way we can use growth perpetuities to analyze the rela- tionship between methods.1 Enterprise Discounted Cash Flow By definition, enterprise value (V) equals the market value of debt (D) plus the market value of equity (E): V D E = + 1 For an analysis that applies to more complex situations (i.e., when cash flows can follow any pat- tern), see J. A. Miles and J. R. Ezzell, “The Weighted Average Cost of Capital, Perfect Capital Markets, and Project Life: A Clarification,” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 15 (1980): 719–730 (for a discussion of enterprise DCF and WACC); and S. C. Myers, “Interactions of Corporate Financing and Investment Decisions: Implications for Capital Budgeting,” Journal of Finance 29 (1974): 1–25 (for a dis- cussion of adjusted present value). 800  Appendix  B To examine the components of enterprise value, multiply the right side of the equation by a complex fraction equivalent to 1 (the numerator equals the denominator, an algebraic trick we will use many times): V D E D T k D g D T k D g m d e m d e = + ( ) − ( ) + − ( ) − ( ) + − ( )       1 1 CF CF  (B.1) where T k m d e = = = marginal tax rate cost of debt CF cash flow to equity holders g = growth in cash flow to equity holders Over the next few steps, the fraction’s numerator will be converted to free cash flow (FCF). We will show later that the denominator equals the weighted average cost of capital. Start by defining the numerator as FCF: FCF CF = − ( ) + − ( ) D T k D g m d e 1 If the market value of debt equals the face value of debt, the cost of debt will equal the coupon rate, and D times kd will equal the company’s interest expense. Therefore, FCF Interest CF = − ( ) + − ( ) 1 T D g m e By definition, cash flow to equity (CFe) equals earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) minus interest, taxes, and net investment, plus the increase in debt. Assuming the ratio of debt to equity is constant, the annual increase in debt will equal D(g). Why? Since cash flows to equity are growing at g, the value of equity also grows at g. Since the ratio of debt to equity remains con- stant (a key assumption), the value of debt must also grow at g. Substitute the definition of cash flow to equity into the preceding equation: FCF Interest EBIT Interest Taxes Net Investment = − ( ) + − − − + ( ) − 1 T D g m D g ( ) Next, distribute the after-tax interest expression into its two components, and cancel D(g): FCF Interest Interest EBIT Interest Taxes Net Investmen = − ( ) + − − − Tm t Simplify by canceling the interest terms and rearranging the remaining terms: FCF EBIT Taxes Interest Net Investment = − + ( ) [ ] − Tm Appendix  B  801 Chapter 11 defines operating taxes as the taxes a company would pay if the company were financed entirely with equity. Operating taxes therefore equal reported taxes plus the interest tax shield (as interest is eliminated, taxes would rise by the interest tax shield). This leads to the definition of free cash flow we use throughout the book: FCF EBIT Operating Taxes Net Investment = − − Next, we focus on the denominator. To derive the weighted average cost of capital (WACC), start with Equation B.1, and multiply CFe by 1, denoted as (ke - g)/(ke - g): V D E D T k k g k g D g m d e e e = + ( ) − ( ) + − − ( ) − ( )             FCF CF 1 where ke = cost of equity. If equity cash flows are growing at a constant rate, the value of equity equals CFe divided by (ke - g). Therefore, the growing perpetuity in the de- nominator can be replaced by the value of equity (E) and distributed: V D E D T k E k E g D g m d e = + ( ) − ( ) + ( ) −( ) − ( )       FCF 1 In the denominator, collapse E(g) and D(g) into a single term: V D E D T k E k D E g m d e = + ( ) − ( ) + ( ) − + ( )       FCF 1 To complete the derivation of WACC in the denominator, divide the nu- merator and denominator by (D + E). This will eliminate the (D + E) expres- sion on the left and place it in the denominator as a divisor. Distributing the term across the denominator, the result is the following equation: V D D E k T E D E k D E D E g d m e = + ( ) − ( ) + + ( ) − + + ( ) FCF 1 The expression in the denominator is the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) minus the growth in cash flow (g). Therefore, Equation B.1 can be rewritten as: V g = − FCF WACC