2026-08-18T07:34:47.753Z	77dfaa6	hook-bold	17		{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":2,"judgeMain":null}
2026-08-18T07:42:10.636Z	249fe10	hook-bold	27		{"lintErrors":1,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":2,"judgeMain":null}
2026-08-18T17:01:44.580Z	b373dc0	hook-bold	NaN	NaN	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":2,"judgeNotes":"","judgeMain":null}
2026-08-18T17:06:41.448Z	b373dc0	hook-bold	21.5	4	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":2,"judgeNotes":"Frames 1 and 6 are entirely empty except the watermark — the opener has no hook and the closer looks accidentally blank rather than a deliberate sign-off, which is roughly a third of the runtime with nothing on screen. Vertical placement is inconsistent without apparent intent: frame 2 sits above ce","judgeMain":3.5}
2026-09-21T22:56:11.672Z	cfd5278	hook-bold	21.5	4	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":2,"judgeNotes":"Consistent dark ground, light text, and a restrained teal accent used only for the watermark — that part of the design language is clean and the type itself is legible with decent line lengths. But execution problems dominate. Frame 1 (0s) is completely empty except the watermark, and frame 6 (15.52","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":3.5}
2026-10-01T21:19:35.404Z	3dc1451	hook-bold	21.5	4	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":2,"judgeNotes":"Frames 1 and 6 are entirely empty except the watermark — the opening frame has no hook at all and the closing frame reads as accidentally blank, which wastes both the scroll-stopping moment and the CTA payoff. Caption vertical placement is inconsistent without apparent intent: frame 2 centers at ~28","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":3.5}
2026-10-01T21:24:52.858Z	118acc8	hook-bold	19.5	5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":3,"judgeNotes":"Consistent dark gradient ground, light text, and a single teal accent used sparingly (watermark + final underline) — the design language is coherent and legible, with comfortable side margins. Problems are mostly hierarchy, motion, and composition: frame 2 and frame 5 are near-empty with a single sh","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":4.5}
2026-10-02T18:13:29.667Z	82474a0	hook-bold	28.5	5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":3,"judgeNotes":"MAIN: Captions are legible and the near-black ground with off-white type is clean, but craft is uneven. Frame 4 ('Golden hour hits the ridge…') renders in a dim grey that reads as a half-faded straggler rather than a finished state, and vertical placement wanders between beats (frames 1-2 sit above ","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":5.5,"metricVersion":2,"references":"dark-kinetic","judgeMatch":4}
2026-10-02T18:16:54.143Z	82474a0	quote-card	26.9	5.5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"Clean dark ground with a single cyan accent and legible light type — glance readability is fine and the 4-line card at 6.4s proves the box can grow without clipping. But the sequence is structurally broken: frame 1 carries only a watermark, the 15.52s final frame is completely empty (the brief and t","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":4.3,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":5.6}
2026-10-02T18:21:53.299Z	82474a0	listicle	16.5	5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":3,"judgeNotes":"Clean, legible execution: dark ground, single cyan accent used consistently for numbered chips, rule under the title and watermark; type is well-sized and nothing clips. Hierarchy works — bold title dominates, captions secondary, watermark small and low. Problems: frame 1 is completely empty (a dead","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":5.5,"metricVersion":2}
2026-10-02T18:29:00.665Z	72e460b	quote-card	20.4	6	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"Clean dark-teal ground with a single cyan accent used consistently (kicker, quote glyph, border, counter, handle), and the bordered card scales to fit a long three-line quote, so legibility is strong at a glance. Weaknesses: frame 1's title is caught mid blur-resolve so the hook reads soft rather th","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6.2,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":6}
2026-10-03T10:07:09.919Z	0da2133	hook-bold	26.6	5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":3,"judgeNotes":"Dark ground, light caps type and a single cyan accent are consistently applied, and the final card (title + accent rule) is a proper held ending rather than an empty frame — those are the strongest parts. But craft slips: frames 1 and 4 render in a muddy mid-grey, reading as half-faded stragglers ca","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":5.2,"metricVersion":2,"references":"dark-kinetic","judgeMatch":5.4}
2026-10-03T10:13:14.349Z	0d41af7	hook-bold	22	5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":3,"judgeNotes":"Palette discipline is the strongest aspect: true near-black ground, heavy condensed off-white caps, and a single cyan accent reserved for one word per beat plus the final card underline — exactly the reference language. Type weight/case/scale also reads as the right genre, and the final frame is a p","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6,"metricVersion":2,"references":"dark-kinetic","judgeMatch":6.5}
2026-10-03T10:19:30.930Z	d7e5f49	hook-bold	34.5	5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":13,"judgeNotes":"Solid fundamentals: near-black ground, heavy all-caps off-white type, a single cyan accent used on one word per beat, and a proper held end card with accent rule — all on-brief. Weaknesses: frame 3 collapses into a seven-line paragraph that cannot be read in under a second and kills the one-idea-per","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":5.5,"metricVersion":2,"references":"dark-kinetic","judgeMatch":6}
2026-10-03T10:25:22.912Z	580a2a2	hook-bold	23	5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":3,"judgeNotes":"Dark teal-black ground, heavy all-caps off-white type and a single cyan accent reserved for one word per beat (7AM, CEDAR, JULY, TRIP) read cleanly, and the held final card with the cyan rule is a proper ending rather than an empty frame. Weaknesses: vertical placement jumps between the top block (f","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6,"metricVersion":2,"references":"dark-kinetic","judgeMatch":6}
2026-10-03T10:31:04.598Z	45fea13	hook-bold	25.4	4.5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":3,"judgeNotes":"Palette discipline is the strongest part: consistent near-black/teal ground, off-white heavy caps and a single cyan accent reserved for one word per beat (7AM, CEDAR, JULY, TRIP) plus the accent rule on the final card, which is properly held and not empty. Problems: frame 3 is a seven-line paragraph","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":5.2,"metricVersion":2,"references":"dark-kinetic","judgeMatch":6}
2026-10-03T10:34:50.306Z	626e1c2	hook-bold	23	5.5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":3,"judgeNotes":"Solid fundamentals: near-black ground with a subtle teal vignette, off-white heavy condensed caps, and a single cyan accent applied to exactly one key word per beat — palette discipline is the strongest aspect, and the held final card with accent rule is a proper ending rather than an empty frame. W","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6,"metricVersion":2,"references":"dark-kinetic","judgeMatch":6}
2026-10-04T10:04:44.340Z	83263a6	quote-card	19.4	6	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"Consistent dark ground with a single cyan accent, generous margins and a quote-card motif that reads instantly — the long caption in frame 3 shows the card grows with the text, so the layout would survive different line counts. Weaknesses are mostly in motion consistency: frame 1's title is caught i","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":6.8}
2026-10-04T10:09:11.332Z	83263a6	quote-card	23.6	6	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"MAIN: Legibility is solid — large bold sans in hairline cards, generous internal padding, consistent kicker and handle, and the hook frame reads clearly. But craft slips hurt it: the caption card drifts vertically with no logic (centred at 3.2s, high at 6.4s, low at 9.6s/12.8s), so the surrounding a","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":5.8,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":5}
2026-10-04T10:14:03.449Z	dc582d9	quote-card	17.8	6	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"Consistent dark ground with a single cyan accent (kicker, rule, quote glyph, index, handle) and light text reads premium and disciplined. The blur-to-sharp card reveal is the right motion idea for the brief and the 3.2s cadence is appropriately slow, with one idea per beat and a held end card. Weakn","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6.4,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":7}
2026-10-04T10:18:28.630Z	bf915bd	quote-card	16.6	6.5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"Clean dark ground with a single cyan accent used consistently across kicker, quote glyph, index and handle — palette discipline is good and every caption is legible at a glance. Blur-to-sharp resolves (frames 1 and 4) read as deliberate focus pulls rather than stragglers, matching the reference moti","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6.8,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":7}
2026-10-04T10:23:09.643Z	5496f41	quote-card	36		{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeMain":null,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":null}
2026-10-04T10:27:32.731Z	5496f41	quote-card	14.3	6.5	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"Clean dark/cyan system: kicker, centered bordered quote card with quote glyph and NN/05 counter, small handle lock-up. Captions are legible with comfortable margins and the card auto-sizes gracefully for the long 02/05 line, so the layout would survive different text lengths. Motion reads as a blur-","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":7.3,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":7.4}
2026-10-04T10:30:41.653Z	b4b3d3b	quote-card	36		{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeMain":null,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":null}
2026-10-04T10:33:49.354Z	b4b3d3b	quote-card	19.4	6.8	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"Clean dark ground with a single cyan accent used consistently (kicker, quote glyph, counter, handle), and the auto-sizing bordered card handles both a three-word line and a four-line quote without cramping, so glance readability is strong and the watermark stays quiet. Weaknesses: the card's vertica","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6.2,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":6.5}
2026-10-04T10:37:02.361Z	81e841f	quote-card	18.6	6	{"lintErrors":0,"runtimeErrors":0,"overflowCount":0,"contrastFails":0,"deadZoneSeconds":0,"pacingFlags":1,"judgeNotes":"Clean dark ground with a single cool cyan accent used consistently (kicker, quote glyph, counter, handle) and comfortable margins; captions are legible at a glance and the card auto-sizes gracefully for the 5-line entry in frame 3, so hierarchy within each frame holds. Weaknesses: the hook frame (1)","judgeModel":"anthropic/claude-opus-5","judgeMain":6.4,"metricVersion":2,"references":"cinematic-quote","judgeMatch":6.6}